collegerankings

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Causal follies: gun control edition

Posted on 5:04 PM by Unknown
The Atlantic Cities column summarizes a study recently published in (ahem) JAMA Internal Medicine.

The study examines cross-sectional correlations between state gun control law strictness and firearms deaths. I have some concerns:

1. An alternative model would be that gun control law severity is a function of the number of firearms deaths. That is, perhaps the causality runs the other way. Or both ways. The cross-sectional "selection on observed variables" design can shed little light on this though some actual leg work on the legislative histories could..

2. The model employed in the study conditions on firearms ownership and on "other violence-related deaths". The first of these is an intermediate outcome, the second is jointly determined with the dependent variable to the extent that firearms and other tools for offing people are substitutes. Nether should be on the right-hand side of the model.

The Atlantic writer is very coy about causality and quotes the author as cautioning that the estimated relationship is only correlational. But that does not stop the Atlantic writer from making a strong causal claim in the last line of the article. I give the Atlantic writer an F.

Finally, I think that my concerns above make it clear why this was published in a medical journal, which is likely ill-equipped to evaluate a study such as this rather than, say, a clinical trial, rather than in a social science journal. This study also reinforces the point I made in an earlier post about it being a bad idea to treat guns as a public health issue rather than a social science one.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Michigan 28, Akron 24
    Dodging a bullet does not even begin to describe this near debacle, with Akron having shots into the end zone on the final four plays! Local...
  • Book: Paying for the Party by Armstrong and Hamilton
    Armstrong, Elizabeth and Laura Hamilton. 2013. Paying for the Party: How College Maintains Inequality . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University P...
  • Assorted links
    1. Rob Mercer on tradition . Why does Canada produce so many good comedians? One suspects it has something to do with living next door to th...
  • In praise of payday lenders
    From the Atlantic, something I never thought I would see: a thoughtful, empirically grounded defense of payday lenders and other alternati...
  • Movie: Jack the Giant Slayer
    Jack the Giant Slayer is, of course, a movie version of the Jack and the Beanstalk story. I pretty much agree with the NYT reviewer down th...
  • Assorted links
    1. Drunken island monkeys . 2. Free speech versus occupational licensing in Kentucky. 3. Virginia Postrel on how to save Barnes and Noble ....
  • Cheaters welcome at Harvard
    This survey of the incoming class , reported in the Harvard Crimson, is a bit troubling. Of course, this is what folks at Chicago suspected ...
  • Assorted links
    1. The goose man . 2. When the mistress of the dead boss sues the company that fired her after he died .  Good stuff. 3. Why I am not a Re...
  • Assorted links
    1. On the history of German restaurants in Ann Arbor. Mainly because it is not within walking distance of campus, I have yet to make it to ...
  • Assorted links
    1. Michigan dorm cafeterias drop their trays . Does this count as an application of behavioral economics? 2. Seattle Public Library breaks ...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (257)
    • ►  September (18)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (58)
    • ►  June (4)
    • ►  May (16)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ▼  March (35)
      • Michigan skit night: faculty staff skit
      • Assorted links
      • Selection bias, anyone?
      • Universities respond to incentives: who knew?
      • The mystery of fascism
      • Robert Heinlein writes to Theodore Sturgeon
      • Movie: Oz the Great and Powerful
      • Jim Hines on NPR on tax havens
      • Michigan skit night - Jim Hines video
      • Assorted links
      • WWC Procedures and Standards Handbook
      • Take a drive (or two or three) through rural Sierr...
      • The married male wage premium
      • Play: Good People
      • New US News economics rankings
      • Movie: Dead Man Down
      • Assorted links
      • Assorted links
      • PDD: science edition
      • A comic in honor of prospective student day
      • On enlightenment
      • Becky Blank to UW-Madison
      • Assorted links
      • Assorted links
      • Causal follies: gun control edition
      • Hookups: pro and con
      • Academic follies: physicist / drug mule / lonely g...
      • Movie: Amour
      • Hugo Chavez, RIP
      • Movie: Jack the Giant Slayer
      • Assorted links
      • Whole Foods comes to Detroit
      • Cheerleading as job training ....
      • Not really a nerd after all ...
      • Causal follies: Illinois basketball edition
    • ►  February (41)
    • ►  January (26)
  • ►  2012 (243)
    • ►  December (47)
    • ►  November (30)
    • ►  October (28)
    • ►  September (45)
    • ►  August (73)
    • ►  July (20)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile