collegerankings

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, August 27, 2012

LaLonde on WIA book

Posted on 12:06 PM by Unknown
Bob Lalonde reviews the recent Upjohn book, edited by Doug Besharov and Phoebe Cottingham, on the Workforce Investment Act (WIA) (journal access required). The book grew out of a mini-conference held to inform the Europeans of the lessons they could learn from the US experience with active labor market programs.

The review has wise words about the difficulties of non-experimental evaluation of active labor market programs like WIA, about the lack of policy response to evaluation results, and about performance management.  I particularly liked this bit on the latter topic:
A very closely related problem turns on the merits of using performance measures to proxy for rigorous impact estimates. Since these measures were first conceived during the CETA program, attempts to refine them so they actually “work” have amounted to the workforce development field's equivalent of the quest for the Holy Grail. Like its predecessor quest, so far this effort has been futile. There is no convincing evidence that using performance measures as a proxy is a good idea and lots of evidence against it. As explained by Burt Barnow in his chapter here, “Lessons from the WIA Performance Measures,” workforce performance measures do not correlate well with program impacts. That really should not be a surprise, because coming up with reliable performance measures requires that we be able to confidently and consistently solve the evaluation problem.
Though nominally aimed at the Europeans, there is much that US policymakers could learn from the book as well. They could also learn from the Europeans (at least some of them) about how to increase the quality of non-experimental program evaluations via better administrative data.

You can order the book from Upjohn (or Amazon) and you can read the final draft of my chapter for free. They made me take out the bit about Farrell's from the book version, so I actually prefer the final draft.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Michigan 28, Akron 24
    Dodging a bullet does not even begin to describe this near debacle, with Akron having shots into the end zone on the final four plays! Local...
  • Book: Paying for the Party by Armstrong and Hamilton
    Armstrong, Elizabeth and Laura Hamilton. 2013. Paying for the Party: How College Maintains Inequality . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University P...
  • Assorted links
    1. Rob Mercer on tradition . Why does Canada produce so many good comedians? One suspects it has something to do with living next door to th...
  • In praise of payday lenders
    From the Atlantic, something I never thought I would see: a thoughtful, empirically grounded defense of payday lenders and other alternati...
  • Movie: Jack the Giant Slayer
    Jack the Giant Slayer is, of course, a movie version of the Jack and the Beanstalk story. I pretty much agree with the NYT reviewer down th...
  • Assorted links
    1. Drunken island monkeys . 2. Free speech versus occupational licensing in Kentucky. 3. Virginia Postrel on how to save Barnes and Noble ....
  • Cheaters welcome at Harvard
    This survey of the incoming class , reported in the Harvard Crimson, is a bit troubling. Of course, this is what folks at Chicago suspected ...
  • Assorted links
    1. The goose man . 2. When the mistress of the dead boss sues the company that fired her after he died .  Good stuff. 3. Why I am not a Re...
  • Assorted links
    1. On the history of German restaurants in Ann Arbor. Mainly because it is not within walking distance of campus, I have yet to make it to ...
  • Assorted links
    1. Michigan dorm cafeterias drop their trays . Does this count as an application of behavioral economics? 2. Seattle Public Library breaks ...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (257)
    • ►  September (18)
    • ►  August (34)
    • ►  July (58)
    • ►  June (4)
    • ►  May (16)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ►  March (35)
    • ►  February (41)
    • ►  January (26)
  • ▼  2012 (243)
    • ►  December (47)
    • ►  November (30)
    • ►  October (28)
    • ►  September (45)
    • ▼  August (73)
      • LaLonde on WIA book
      • Movie: ParaNorman
      • What Jim Tressel is up to
      • Move over Tina Fey
      • You might be a redneck if ...
      • FT on corporate mindfulness
      • Booth School reunion
      • Life after the NFL
      • The Economist on Romney
      • Assorted links
      • Tyler's sobering thought
      • Assorted links
      • This sounds really familiar ...
      • Lunch changes at the Ann Arbor public schools
      • Why UM lost to Appalachian State ....
      • Economists for Romney (or Obama)
      • Book: Understanding the Dead Sea Scrolls, by Hersh...
      • Miles Kimball's blog
      • Books: Crossing the Finish Line
      • The advance of our robot overlords
      • Assorted links
      • Drezner on dissertation prospectuses
      • Movie: The Odd Life of Timothy Green
      • I pronounce a curse on ebay
      • Bieber graduates!
      • Subsidizing economics
      • Economics Moment of Zen #5
      • Supplier induced demand
      • Uncle Bonsai and Chrstine Lavin in Sterling Heights
      • The Kochtopus and Little House on the Prarie
      • Big Ten Network cuts academic programming
      • Reading the readers of 50 Shades of Grey
      • Assorted links
      • Regression discontinuity goes to the Olympics
      • KC and the Sunshine Band
      • God in silicon valley
      • Others read it so you don't have to
      • Economics Moment of Zen #4
      • Bertrand Russell's 10 Commandments
      • The Obama that I used to know
      • Economics Moment of Zen #3
      • Justin Bieber saved my life
      • Assorted links
      • News about the downtown Borders space ...
      • IZA Prize in Labor Economics to Richard Blundell
      • An excellent Dilbert
      • Movie: Total Recall (2012)
      • Marcin and the primary
      • White Market closing
      • My papers on my web page
      • Productivity advice for academics
      • Movie: James and the Giant Peach
      • Deaton v. Banerjee on RCTs
      • What foreigners think of the US
      • Assorted links
      • The Far Side on non-classical measurement error
      • What the pill wrought
      • First Husky football post for the fall
      • Mixed marriages
      • Mommy, where did 50 Shades of Grey come from?
      • Book: The Trouble with Tom, by Paul Collins
      • Book: Forged, by Bart Ehrman
      • Zombie neighborhoods
      • Movie: Your Sister's Sister
      • Pre-internet blogging
      • The Chronicle approves
      • Mechanism design, badminton, and job training
      • UM observatory
      • Fred Willard
      • More on Marcin
      • The division of book topics is limited by the exte...
      • On vague advice from faculty
      • Warsh on LIBOR
    • ►  July (20)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile